We get asked this question a lot and there continues to be much confusion about this subject.
First of all, it is not OK to make someone a “contractor” or “subcontractor” just because that is how they want to be treated.
Employee vs. contractor boils down a matter of control. If a person works for your company, does not have their own business, does not perform similar services for other businesses, if they have to work set days and hours for you and if the person works for you on a continual basis, they are an employee and should be treated as such. You should have them fill out the proper employment forms (W-4, I-4 and I-9) and you should withhold Social Security, Medicare and the proper federal and state income taxes from their pay. This is true for both full-time and part-time employees.
If the person only works for you on a particular project, provides their own tools or equipment, has their own business, sets their own hours and does this type of work for other companies, they can be treated as a contractor. Basically, you have contracted them for a particular project or a set amount of time. You would simply pay them without any withholdings. You will need them to fill out a form W-9 before you pay them and you must send them a 1099 at the end of the year if you pay them $600 or more during the calendar year. Keep in mind that business tax returns ask if your company issued 1099s to anyone for whom you paid over $600. You must answer “yes” or “no”.
A person cannot be both an employee and a contractor. It is always better to get them to fill out the W-9 up front, even if you are not sure how much you will pay them, since you may not be able to find them at the end of the year when you need their information for a 1099. We find that most contractors do not want to receive a 1099. Wonder why? Maybe not to report the income???
Scott T. Stafford